Countries don’t typically get report cards, but there are hard facts that can be collated, assessed and compared. Enter Benchmark Canada, a new project from the Macdonald-Laurier Institute that brings together more than 40 different metrics that measure this nation’s performance. This fall, the National Post is examining many of those findings.
Canada is struggling to retain its high-potential startups, with far-reaching implications for the broader economy.
A study conducted by Toronto-based venture capitalists Leaders Fund in 2025 found that only 32 per cent of Canadian-founded high-potential startups — or those that have raised at least $1 million from venture capitalists — were headquartered in Canada as of 2024. Meanwhile, 48 per cent relocated across the border, and another 20 per cent established a headquarters in the European Union.
Between 2015 and 2020, Canada retained between 60 and 75 per cent of its high-potential startups before experiencing successively larger exoduses with each passing year for the following five.
Gideon Hayden, the co-founder and managing partner of Leaders Fund, says it’s hard to know for sure what changed after 2020, but speculates that a combination of factors were at play.
“The pandemic, no doubt in my mind, had a huge impact, even just on the way we work,” he says, suggesting remote work made relocation easier. “We also lived through some of the most restrictive COVID policies in the world, and for anyone building a business, that posed a challenge.”
Hayden adds that Canada has historically retained its startup founders by offering a high quality of life, but by the early 2020s that advantage was slipping. “When those metrics started to trend in the wrong direction, that maybe made the decision easier for folks,” he says.
There are broader societal benefits to these innovation clusters that go beyond just firms’ employment and tax dollars
The final nail in the coffin, however, was the Trudeau government’s planned increase to the inclusion rate for capital gains taxes in Budget 2024, effectively taking a bigger bite out of successful startup founders’ payday when they exit the business.
That might also help explain a recent modest reversal, which followed Prime Minister Mark Carney’s decision to cancel his predecessor’s planned changes to capital gains taxes. “There’s definitely a (different) vibe happening where we have a more serious person leading the country, and that capital gains hike was cancelled,” Hayden says.
After five consecutive years of declines, the latest Leaders Fund study (which will be published exclusively in Financial Post on Dec. 1) shows some signs of improvement. In 2025, 40 per cent of Canadian-founded, high-potential startups remained in the country, largely due to declines in European relocation. That marks the first year-over-year improvement since 2018, but the country’s startup retention rate remains well below former averages.
The recent reversal is welcome news for Canadians within and beyond the innovation ecosystem. That’s because startup founders are uniquely positioned to deliver economic prosperity in new and innovative ways.
“We don’t inherently care about the number of entrepreneurs that live in Canada. At the end of the day, we care about productivity growth, and we care about our standard of living. Full stop,” says Francis Fong, a managing director and senior economist at TD Bank. “There are broader societal benefits to these innovation clusters that go beyond just firms’ employment and tax dollars.”
In a recent report, Fong labelled this exodus “Canada’s Silent Brain Drain,” noting that Canada was barely noticing the loss of some of its most economically important citizens. In fact, the report went so far as to suggest that Canada was acting as a “feeder system” to the United States’ innovation economy.
“We create the feeder system by dedicating public tax dollars to research, but not to helping the individuals that develop products and services in actually bringing them to market,” he says. “We are basically helping other countries.”
Editor’s Picks
It wasn’t always this way. Fong explains that in the decade prior to 2016, Canada saw some of the highest productivity and growth metrics in the G7, thanks in large part to a significant corporate tax advantage over the United States.
“The U.S. has made substantive efforts to improve the competitiveness of their own tax systems, and that tax advantage is now gone,” he says. “If you look at the general corporate income tax statutory rate from a combined federal-provincial versus federal-state level, we are now on par. So, if you’re going to pay a particular tax rate, why not do it in the U.S., where you can access deeper capital markets and a larger consumer market?”
Though it’s unlikely Canada will be able to offer its businesses a more generous tax rate than its southern neighbour, Fong says the country can do more to lower some of the regulatory barriers that hurt startups more than they benefit society.
“A regulation is designed to protect consumers, society, the environment, something — and it’s a difficult decision for the government to say, ‘we’re going to deprioritize this,'” he says. “That’s a hard conversation, but I think it’s one that we at least need to begin.”
In a follow-up survey with 24 Canadian founders who relocated to the United States, Leaders Fund found the most common motivation for moving was to access a larger consumer market. That was followed by access to venture capital funding, a culture of ambition and risk-taking, and then talent density. However, when asked what would lure them back, almost all cited a more favourable tax environment.
Hayden explains that policymakers and governments can’t make a startup successful on their own, but they can play a role in creating the conditions that enable them to win.
“What countries can do is try (to) make that environment more conducive and create less friction in building a company,” he says. “That can take the form of reducing capital gains to incentivize more entrepreneurs to build here, making the government procurement process way faster to meet the timelines of a startup, making it easier for companies to recruit international talent — these things make a difference.”
National Post